Tag Team Title History | # | Holder | Date Won |
| 01 | RJ Palmer & Anjeleka Slater | 04/11/12 |
| 02 | Psico Payaso & Aaliyah Monroe | 05/05/12 |
| 03 | Psico & Arsenic | 05/19/12 |
| 04 | Raymond Hatcher & Tyler Decker | 07/21/12 |
| 05 | T. Slater & R. Cross | 10/01/12 |
| 06 | T. Slater & Mark Flynn | 10/29/12 |
| 07 | Sid Feder & Mark Flynn (2) | 12/01/12 |
| 08 | Vacated | 01/14/13 |
| 09 | Peter Gilmour | 01/24/13 |
| 10 | Peter Gilmour & Poppa Feder | 02/23/13 |
| 11 | Crimson Cobra & Knightmask "The Crimson Knights" | 05/25/13 |
| 12 | Eric Rex &Eli JamesMystica "The Congregation" | 07/13/13 |
| 13 | Griffin MacAlister & Sebastian Duke "The Brotherhood" | 08/07/13 |
| 14 | Griffin MacAlister | 03/26/14 |
| 15 | Scorpio & Frodo Smackins | 05/07/14 |
| 16 | Peter Gilmour (2) & The Dimallisher "Team Special" | 06/21/14 |
| 17 | Kendall Sawyer & Azrael Erebus | 08/13/14 |
| 18 | Kendall Sawyer (Prev.) & Next Level Meta | 12/10/14 |
| 19 | Pest & JACK | 12/10/14 |
| 20(Freebird Rules Now Apply to Tag Team Titles) | Theo Pryce/John Samuels/John Madison "The Kings" | 12/29/14 |
| 21 | Justine Sane/CorVus/Gator "Defiance" | 01/27/15 |
| 22 | Maverick and Scully | 04/08/15 |
| 23 | "Lucky No. 7" Carson Waters and Flynn Andrew Cole-Ericson "Brick Squad" | 04/22/15 (Vacated on 08/02/15) |
| 24 | "Mr. F'N Dominance" Trax and Lux Lyden | 09/01/2015 |
| 25 | Austin Fernando and Luca Arzegotti "FernGotti" | 01/30/16 |
| 26 | Sir Chris Macbeth and Scully "The Union" | 04/06/16 |
| 27 | Makaveli and Peter Gilmour (3) "The Resistance" | 05/25/16 (Makaveli stripped on 07/22/16) |
| 28 | Peter Gilmour (4) and Michael McBride | 07/22/2016 |
| 29 | Kandi Washington and Jake Wakefield - Stripped for severe cunting | 08/03/16 |
| 30 | Robbie Bourbon and "Arby Beef" (Scully) - Found belts in trash | 08/16/16 |
| 31 | Dr. D'Ville and Unknown Soldier "Doctor Satan" | 09/28/16 |
| 32 D'Ville was forced to replace Unknown Soldier | Dr. D'Ville, John Madison, Theo Pryce and John Samules "The Kings" | 04/19/17 |
| 33 Doc D'Ville relinquished the tag titles as a prize for Shove It Where The Sun Don't Shine II | Chris Chaos & Jim Caedus | 11/26/17 |
| 34 The Engineer cashes in on Chris Chaos's half of the tag team titles | The Engineer & Jim Caedus | 12/23/17 |
| 35 | Chris Chaos (2) and Peter Gilmour (5) | 04/11/18 |
| 36 | Micheal Graves (2) and Cadryn Tiberius | 06/27/18 |
| 37 | Bilbo Blumpkinz and Sebasstian Duke(BX3) | 08/01/18 |
| 38 | Peter Gilmour (6) and Drezdin | 08/29/18 |
| 39 | "The Midnight Dolls" Jessalyn Hart and Vita Valenteen | 09/14/18 |
| 40 | "Purebred Killers"(2) Peter Gilmour (7) and Michael McBride(2) | 09/29/18 |
| 41 | "The Midnight Dolls"(2) Jessalyn Hart and Vita Valenteen(2) | 12/19/18 |
| 42 | "Apex" Robert Main and Drew Archyle | 01/16/19 |
| 43 | "The Arm Collectors - Steve Justice and Hanari Carnes | 09/14/19 |
| 44 | "5'2" Mafia" Sarah Lacklan and Kenzi Grey | 09/29/19 |
| 45 | "The Sick Cunts - Fuzz and Noah Jackson | 01/26/20 |
| 46 | Cataclysm - Chronic Chris Page and Robert The Omega Main (2) | 03/29/20 |
| 47 | Continuum (Thaddeus Duke, Doc D'ville & Corey Smith) | 11/29/20 |
| 48 | Them No Good Bastards (Bobby Bourbon & Thunder Knuckles) | 03/28/21 |
| 49 | Mark Flynn(3) & North Korean War Criminal | 10/20/21 |
| 50 | "Apex" Jim Caedus, Robert Main (3) and Drew Archyle (2) | 11/28/21 |
| 51 | Mark Flynn(4) & North Korean War Criminal (2) | 01/30/22 |
| 52 | "VACATED | 08/28/22 |
| 53 | Dolly Waters and Vita Valenteen (3) | 09/23/22 |
| 54 | "Angie Vaughn and John Madison Jr | 10/29/22 |
| 55 | Dolly Waters (2) and Charlie Nickles | 01/14/23 |
| 56 | "Angie Vaughn(2) and Sarah Lacklan (2) | 01/29/23 |
| 57 | Raion Kido and Jason Cashe | 03/26/23 |
| 58 | "The Just Us League" The Atomic Bat and The Blue Tango | 05/02/23 |
| 59 | "The Good Guys" Bobby Bourbon (2) and Mark Flynn (5) | 11/26/23 |
| 60 | Isaiah King and Ned Kaye | 12/23/23 |
| 61 | Lucy Wylde & Aurora | 11/4/24 |
| 62 | Dolly Waters (3) & Madison Dyson | 01/26/25 |
| 63 | Isaiah King (2) & Sebastian Everett-Bryce | 06/01/25 |
| 64 | Dr. Holly Cambric & Emilia Glazkov | 06/30/25 |
| 65 | Isaiah King (3) & Sebastian Everett-Bryce (2) | 06/01/25 |
| 66 | Sebastian Everett-Bryce (3) | 11/23/25 |