Just a thought but i think sometimes its better to only have a small number of regular judges, that way they know the characters involved, their history, the significance of events etc. Some people dont recap in their rps and could suffer for that with one off judges. You could make the argument that not recapping is a weakness but i think people should be judged on their work not whether it totally makes sense to people unaware of the arc.

Not saying this for my benefit btw, just came to mind when i was replying to Matt Lennox in the predictions thread. Theres also the danger of people subconsciously placing well known peoples work over new people's that affects judging.